Fair to say that the last few hours the Hockey world has exploded with the news of two big trades involving the Oilers, Canadiens, Predators and New Jersey Devils. Meanwhile, Steven Stamkos resigned with the Tampa. Which was funnily enough the smallest of the three stories.
The first trade to break was the trade involving the Edmonton Oilers and New Jersey Devils involving Taylor Hall, taking 1st overall in 2010. In exchange for this they got Adam Larsson from the New Jersey Devils, taken 4th overall in 2011. I don't watch either of these teams a lot but I understand that Edmonton needed help on defence and New Jersey were looking for help offensively.
But, I feel like New Jersey had less to lose as Damon Severson could take his spot in the line-up. The Oilers have been making sounds for a while about moving a forward but most expected it not to be a top tier guy like Taylor Hall. Yakupov was mentioned a lot with the likelihood that they would then target someone in free agency. There are pitiful to that but they're not as bad as moving a guy like Hall.
There's no denying that Adam Larsson is a dependable guy with a lot of promise and talent, but he is yet to show it whilst Taylor Hall has been a constant threat offensively on an Oilers organisation that has been awful for a few seasons. I feel like the Oilers will regret this trade, especially when they're likely to sign Milan Lucic to replace him. Puljujarvi will be a joker in the pack as well, the Oilers seem to be hinging on him to provide as well to replace Hall. That is a big ask on a recently drafted player.
As if that trade wasn't enough, the Montreal Canadiens outdid the Oilers by traded PK Subban to the Nashville Predators in exchange for Shea Weber. Both players are great defencemen and have great assets to their game. They both play defence well and have booming shots that make them a huge threat to opposition teams. However, I feel Subban is a better player.
There are minor signs last year that Weber is declining in the nuances of the game such as possession and corsi chances for and against. He is also on a much longer contract than Subban and it carries him into his late 30's and early 40's. That's a really troubling area for any player as some can really drop off that late and not recover causing their team problems.
Subban's contract however runs through until he is 33 years old, meaning he will be, ideally for Nashville, coming out of his peak years. The actual money in Subban's contract is slightly greater than Webers at $58m to $54m but the length makes it a real win for the Predators.
I think the biggest affect in this trade though would be the effect on the local charities and community in Montreal that PK Subban was a huge contributor to. He gave a lot of time and money to great causes and whilst in his goodbye message he said he would continue, there are going to be some upset people, upset at losing such a great member of their community and someone who generally helped any way he can. Shea Weber could no doubt end up doing the same but the community grew up with PK Subban, so much so that a wing of a local Children's Hospital is named after him. There will be some wounds there, but over time they'll heal.
All in all, I think the Canadiens and Oilers made bad moves that don't help them going forward and will cause them headaches going down the line. But, I guess we will have to see if this holds up.
The first trade to break was the trade involving the Edmonton Oilers and New Jersey Devils involving Taylor Hall, taking 1st overall in 2010. In exchange for this they got Adam Larsson from the New Jersey Devils, taken 4th overall in 2011. I don't watch either of these teams a lot but I understand that Edmonton needed help on defence and New Jersey were looking for help offensively.
But, I feel like New Jersey had less to lose as Damon Severson could take his spot in the line-up. The Oilers have been making sounds for a while about moving a forward but most expected it not to be a top tier guy like Taylor Hall. Yakupov was mentioned a lot with the likelihood that they would then target someone in free agency. There are pitiful to that but they're not as bad as moving a guy like Hall.
There's no denying that Adam Larsson is a dependable guy with a lot of promise and talent, but he is yet to show it whilst Taylor Hall has been a constant threat offensively on an Oilers organisation that has been awful for a few seasons. I feel like the Oilers will regret this trade, especially when they're likely to sign Milan Lucic to replace him. Puljujarvi will be a joker in the pack as well, the Oilers seem to be hinging on him to provide as well to replace Hall. That is a big ask on a recently drafted player.
As if that trade wasn't enough, the Montreal Canadiens outdid the Oilers by traded PK Subban to the Nashville Predators in exchange for Shea Weber. Both players are great defencemen and have great assets to their game. They both play defence well and have booming shots that make them a huge threat to opposition teams. However, I feel Subban is a better player.
There are minor signs last year that Weber is declining in the nuances of the game such as possession and corsi chances for and against. He is also on a much longer contract than Subban and it carries him into his late 30's and early 40's. That's a really troubling area for any player as some can really drop off that late and not recover causing their team problems.
Subban's contract however runs through until he is 33 years old, meaning he will be, ideally for Nashville, coming out of his peak years. The actual money in Subban's contract is slightly greater than Webers at $58m to $54m but the length makes it a real win for the Predators.
I think the biggest affect in this trade though would be the effect on the local charities and community in Montreal that PK Subban was a huge contributor to. He gave a lot of time and money to great causes and whilst in his goodbye message he said he would continue, there are going to be some upset people, upset at losing such a great member of their community and someone who generally helped any way he can. Shea Weber could no doubt end up doing the same but the community grew up with PK Subban, so much so that a wing of a local Children's Hospital is named after him. There will be some wounds there, but over time they'll heal.
All in all, I think the Canadiens and Oilers made bad moves that don't help them going forward and will cause them headaches going down the line. But, I guess we will have to see if this holds up.






















